Judiciary Committee

Judiciary Committee's 19th Meeting of 2024

22 Aug 2024 Number 19

Summary

In today’s meeting, committee discussed the matter sent to committee regarding the motion on removal of Prosecutor General Uz. Hussain Shameem on the matter in accordance with Section 232(b) of the Standing order.

Regarding this issue, before meeting with the Prosecutor General, Thulusdhoo Constituency Member Ibrahim Naseem proposed to have a closed-door meeting for PG to respond to this motion. This proposal was seconded by North Feydhoo Constituency Member Ismail Nizar.

This proposal was passed unanimously with 8 votes. 


Second proposal regarding this matter was to have the meeting open to public. This was proposed by Kendhoo Constituency Member Mauroof Zakir and seconded by South Hithadhoo Constituency Member Ibrahim Naazil. This proposal was not passed. 


Then, the committee invited the prosecutor general to hear his response to the allegations against him in the motion proposed to the parliament by Hulhudhoo Constituency Member Mohamed Shahid.

After meeting with the PG, Committee decided to make a decision on this motion.

The first proposal was to declare there is no legal basis for the removal of the Prosecutor General from his position. This proposal was proposed by Kendhoo Constituency Member Mauroof Zakir and seconded by South Hithadhoo Constituency Member Ibrahim Nazil. This proposal was not passed. 


Second proposal was to remove prosecutor general from his position under the article 228 (a) of the constitution.

This article states;

228. The Prosecutor General shall be removed from office only for the reasons specified in article (a) and in the manner specified in article (b):

Section (a) states “on the ground of misconduct, incapacity or incompetence;”

This was proposed by North Feydhoo Constituency Member Ismail Nizar and seconded by Central Fuvahmulak Constituency Member Ali Fazad. This proposal was passed with the majority of 8 members. 


Attendance

Husnee Mubarik

Manadhoo

Present

Abdul Sattar Mohamed

Holhudhoo

Present

Mauroof Zakir

Kendhoo

Present

Mohamed Shamin Habeeb

Kurendhoo

Present

Dr. Anara Naeem

Huraa

Present

Ibrahim Nazil

South Hithadhoo

Present

Ismail Nizar

North Feydhoo

Present

Ali Fazad

Central Fuvahmulah

Present

Ahmed Riyaz

Thimarafushi

Present

Hassan Mufeed Abdul Gadir

Milandhoo

Present

Ibrahim Naseem

Thulusdhoo

Present

Votes

Vote Details

Husnee Mubarik

Manadhoo

Chairperson

Abdul Sattar Mohamed

Holhudhoo

Yes

Mauroof Zakir

Kendhoo

Absent

Mohamed Shamin Habeeb

Kurendhoo

Yes

Dr. Anara Naeem

Huraa

Yes

Ibrahim Nazil

South Hithadhoo

Absent

Ismail Nizar

North Feydhoo

Seconded By
Yes

Ali Fazad

Central Fuvahmulah

Yes

Ahmed Riyaz

Thimarafushi

Yes

Hassan Mufeed Abdul Gadir

Milandhoo

Yes

Ibrahim Naseem

Thulusdhoo

Proposed By
Yes
Total
11
Yes
8
Voted
8
Present
9
No
0
Not Voted
0
Eligible
8
Abstain
0
Vote Required
5
Total
11
Present
9
Eligible
8
Yes
8
No
0
Abstain
0
Voted
8
Not Voted
0
Vote Required
5

Vote Details

Husnee Mubarik

Manadhoo

Abdul Sattar Mohamed

Holhudhoo

No

Mauroof Zakir

Kendhoo

Proposed By
Yes

Mohamed Shamin Habeeb

Kurendhoo

No

Dr. Anara Naeem

Huraa

No

Ibrahim Nazil

South Hithadhoo

Seconded By
Yes

Ismail Nizar

North Feydhoo

No

Ali Fazad

Central Fuvahmulah

No

Ahmed Riyaz

Thimarafushi

No

Hassan Mufeed Abdul Gadir

Milandhoo

No

Ibrahim Naseem

Thulusdhoo

No
Total
11
Yes
2
Voted
10
Present
11
No
8
Not Voted
0
Eligible
11
Abstain
0
Vote Required
6
Total
11
Present
11
Eligible
11
Yes
2
No
8
Abstain
0
Voted
10
Not Voted
0
Vote Required
6

Vote Details

Husnee Mubarik

Manadhoo

Chairperson

Abdul Sattar Mohamed

Holhudhoo

No

Mauroof Zakir

Kendhoo

Proposed By
Yes

Mohamed Shamin Habeeb

Kurendhoo

No

Dr. Anara Naeem

Huraa

No

Ibrahim Nazil

South Hithadhoo

Seconded By
Yes

Ismail Nizar

North Feydhoo

No

Ali Fazad

Central Fuvahmulah

No

Ahmed Riyaz

Thimarafushi

No

Hassan Mufeed Abdul Gadir

Milandhoo

No

Ibrahim Naseem

Thulusdhoo

No
Total
11
Yes
2
Voted
10
Present
11
No
8
Not Voted
0
Eligible
10
Abstain
0
Vote Required
6
Total
11
Present
11
Eligible
10
Yes
2
No
8
Abstain
0
Voted
10
Not Voted
0
Vote Required
6

Vote Details

Husnee Mubarik

Manadhoo

Chairperson

Abdul Sattar Mohamed

Holhudhoo

Yes

Mauroof Zakir

Kendhoo

No

Mohamed Shamin Habeeb

Kurendhoo

Yes

Dr. Anara Naeem

Huraa

Yes

Ibrahim Nazil

South Hithadhoo

No

Ismail Nizar

North Feydhoo

Proposed By
Yes

Ali Fazad

Central Fuvahmulah

Seconded By
Yes

Ahmed Riyaz

Thimarafushi

Yes

Hassan Mufeed Abdul Gadir

Milandhoo

Yes

Ibrahim Naseem

Thulusdhoo

Yes
Total
11
Yes
8
Voted
10
Present
11
No
2
Not Voted
0
Eligible
10
Abstain
0
Vote Required
6
Total
11
Present
11
Eligible
10
Yes
8
No
2
Abstain
0
Voted
10
Not Voted
0
Vote Required
6

Works

14 Aug 2024

Motion on removal of Prosecutor General Uz. Hussain Shameem to the Standing Committee on the matter in accordance with Section 232(sh) of the Standing order

Completed

13 Aug 2024

Motion on removal of Prosecutor General Uz. Hussain Shameem (Proposed by Hulhudhoo Constituency Member Mohamed Shahid)

Completed

Attendance Summary

  • Present
    11
  • Absent
    00
  • Simultaneous Committee
    00
  • Sick Leave
    00
  • Leave
    00
  • Official
    00
  • Attendance Not Required
    00

Related Documents

  • Select a Parliament

© 2024 Parliament of MaldivesA